actually my father is a syed (naqvi)and my mom is a sunni so i all my life was confused to b honest but since last year i started my own research in london and now i m a complete shia beacuse i have found many ref in sunni books regarding what they do not believe i do discussions with a ahle hadith friend though my research in still on its way my question is who killed uthman the so called third caliph of islam and why did not mawla ALI a.s not find his murderer and punished them. . Masla # 1919


Print version	Print version	Print version
Question ID
Mujtahid Name	Aayat-ul-Allah Khamnaie
Question	actually my father is a syed (naqvi)and my mom is a sunni so i all my life was confused to b honest but since last year i started my own research in london and now i m a complete shia beacuse i have found many ref in sunni books regarding what they do not believe i do discussions with a ahle hadith friend though my research in still on its way my question is who killed uthman the so called third caliph of islam and why did not mawla ALI a.s not find his murderer and punished them.
Answer	bismehi taala, 1) Hazrat Ali a.s. usman ko mazloom nahi samjhte the mgar is tarh qatal karna bhi achha nahi samjhte the (ref:tarikhe tibri jild 3 page 254) 2) khud hazrate ayesha ne usaman k liye kaha tha "yeh naasal yahudi ho gya he use qatal kar do" (ref:tarikhe tibri jild 3 page 76) 3)Hazrat Ali a.s. pure arasae khilafat Aap a.s. k khilaf ki jane wali jangho ka muqabla karne me masroof rahe. 4) usman ke qatilo me Mohammab bin abi bakr shamil the, aur ek riwayat k mutabiq unhone tisre khalifa ki dathi pakdi huee thi, jis par tisre khalifa ne kha k tumhare bap ne kbhi mere sath aysa suluk nahi kiya, Mohammad bin abi bakr ne jawab diya k tum ne mere bap ke waqat aysi harkatain bhi nahi ki thi.
Answered By	Quran-o-Itrat Academy
Topic